St. Augustine Homes for Sale — America's Oldest City, Atlantic Beaches, Historic Architecture & Coastal Living

Founded in 1565 — 42 years before Jamestown and 55 years before Plymouth — St. Augustine is the oldest continuously inhabited European-established city in the United States, and it lives every bit of its 460 years of history. Cobblestone streets lined with Spanish colonial architecture lead to the Castillo de San Marcos, Flagler College, and a pedestrian-only St. George Street filled with galleries, restaurants, and shops. Cross the iconic Bridge of Lions to Anastasia Island for white-sand Atlantic beaches, the St. Augustine Lighthouse, and 1,600 acres of pristine state park.

From restored Victorian homes in Lincolnville to oceanfront estates on St. Augustine Beach, from bayfront condos to gated golf communities at Marsh Creek — St. Augustine pairs a lifestyle found nowhere else in Florida with St. Johns County's #1-ranked schools and the lowest property taxes in Northeast Florida. Explore the latest listings below.

Historic Homes Waterfront Beachfront Under $500K $500K–$1M Over $1M Condos & Townhomes Pool Homes Gated Communities New Listings

Explore Nearby Communities

St. Augustine is the county seat of St. Johns County, which extends north to Jacksonville's border. Browse nearby areas for different styles, price points, and lifestyles throughout the county.

St. Johns County

County-wide overview. Florida's #1 schools, lowest taxes in NE FL, Palencia, SilverLeaf, World Golf Village, Shearwater.

Nocatee

20 min north. America's top-selling master-planned community. Two water parks, 31+ miles trails, A-rated schools.

Ponte Vedra Beach

25 min north. TPC Sawgrass, THE PLAYERS Championship, oceanfront estates, Guana Preserve. $500K–$10M+.

Julington Creek

20 min north. 4,200+ acres, 45+ neighborhoods, Durbin Crossing, top-rated schools, family amenities.

Mandarin

30 min north in Duval County. St. Johns River, established character, mature oaks, accessible prices.

Jacksonville Beach

35 min north. 4.1 miles Atlantic shoreline, walkable dining & nightlife, beach culture, Duval County.

Atlantic Beach

40 min north. Walkable oceanfront village, Town Center shops, local restaurants, Duval County.

Bartram

25 min north. Master-planned communities with resort amenities, nature preserve, family-focused.

St. Augustine Community Snapshot

America's oldest city pairs 460 years of history, Atlantic Ocean beaches, and world-class cultural attractions with Florida's #1-ranked schools and the lowest property taxes in Northeast Florida.

Price Range & Property Types

  • Median home price: ~$450,000–$560,000 (varies by neighborhood)
  • Historic downtown homes: $350,000–$2M+ (Victorian, Colonial, Craftsman)
  • Anastasia Island / Davis Shores: $500,000–$3M+ (median ~$594K–$665K)
  • St. Augustine Beach oceanfront: $600,000–$3M+
  • Vilano Beach: $400,000–$1.5M+
  • Gated golf communities (Marsh Creek): $500,000–$1M+
  • Condos & townhomes: $225,000–$750,000
  • Zips: 32080, 32084, 32086 • St. Johns County

Location & Commute

History, Culture & Recreation

  • Castillo de San Marcos — 17th-century coquina fort (oldest masonry fort in US)
  • St. George Street pedestrian district • 40+ annual festivals
  • Flagler College / Lightner Museum (Gilded Age Flagler-era hotels)
  • St. Augustine Lighthouse (1871) • Alligator Farm Zoological Park
  • Anastasia State Park — 1,600 acres, beaches, trails, camping
  • Bridge of Lions • Fountain of Youth • Fort Matanzas • Intracoastal boating

Schools & Education

  • St. Johns County School District — #1 in Florida, 7 consecutive years
  • R.B. Hunt Elementary (highly rated, Anastasia Island)
  • Sebastian Middle School • St. Augustine High School
  • Flagler College — "Best Value College" (U.S. News)
  • Univ. of St. Augustine for Health Sciences
  • Florida School for the Deaf and Blind (state-supported residential)

Dining, Shopping & Lifestyle

  • St. George Street — galleries, restaurants, boutiques, cafes
  • Catch 27 (seafood) • The Prohibition Kitchen • Columbia Restaurant
  • St. Augustine Beach pier — splashpark, playground, shops, restaurants
  • Local artisan scene • First Friday art shows at Plaza de la Constitution
  • Weekly St. Augustine Farmers Market • Francis Field events
  • Flagler Hospital & Baptist Health for healthcare

Who Lives in St. Augustine?

St. Augustine draws people who want more than a house — they want a lifestyle that connects history, culture, coastal beauty, and community. History and architecture enthusiasts find homes in the downtown neighborhoods where restored Victorians, Spanish Colonial Revival estates, and Craftsman bungalows line streets that have been walked for over four centuries. Beach lovers settle on Anastasia Island, from the established Davis Shores across the Bridge of Lions to the oceanfront properties of St. Augustine Beach. Retirees and second-home buyers appreciate the mild climate, walkable downtown, healthcare access at Flagler Hospital, and the relaxed pace of a small coastal city. Families choose St. Augustine for the #1-ranked St. Johns County schools combined with beach access and cultural richness that no other school district in Florida can match. Artists, writers, and creative professionals are drawn to the galleries, festivals, and the aesthetic inspiration of a city that looks like nowhere else in the state. Boaters and anglers find protected Intracoastal access with multiple outlets to the Atlantic.

Why St. Augustine?

There is simply no other city like this in Florida — or in the United States. St. Augustine is the only place where you can walk cobblestone streets past a 17th-century Spanish fort, dine at a restaurant in a Gilded Age hotel, cross an iconic drawbridge to a barrier island, and surf Atlantic waves — all before lunch. It delivers the cultural depth of Charleston or Savannah with the beach access of the Florida coast, the best public schools in the state, the lowest property taxes in the region, and none of the state income tax. Whether your home is a restored Victorian a block from Flagler College, a waterfront condo overlooking the bayfront, or an oceanfront retreat on St. Augustine Beach, you're living in a place that people travel across the world to visit — and you get to call it home.

Your Guide to Living in St. Augustine

Daily Life in St. Augustine

Life in St. Augustine moves at a different pace. Morning coffee comes with a walk along the bayfront or the beach, not a highway commute. St. George Street and the historic district offer pedestrian-friendly shopping, dining, and culture steps from residential neighborhoods. The weekly St. Augustine Amphitheatre hosts national acts, while Francis Field and the Plaza de la Constitution provide intimate spaces for farmers markets, art shows, and community events. For daily errands, Publix, Target, and retail centers line the southern corridors along US-1 and Dixie Highway. Anastasia Island residents cross the Bridge of Lions for downtown or head south on A1A for beach pier dining and shops. Over 40 festivals throughout the year — from the Celtic Festival to the Nights of Lights holiday celebration — keep the city's cultural calendar full. And for those who commute, I-95 connects to Jacksonville in 35 minutes.

Homes & Real Estate

St. Augustine's real estate spans nearly five centuries of architecture, from Spanish colonial originals to brand-new oceanfront construction. The city proper covers about 13 square miles, with distinct neighborhoods offering dramatically different living experiences.

Historic Downtown

Lincolnville, Fullerwood, Abbott Tract, North City • $350K–$2M+ • Victorian, Colonial, Craftsman • Walkable to Flagler, Fort, St. George St

Anastasia Island & Beaches

Davis Shores, St. Aug Beach, Marsh Creek • $400K–$3M+ • Oceanfront, Intracoastal views • Bridge of Lions access • Gated options

Vilano Beach & North

Vilano Beach, Villages of Vilano • $400K–$1.5M+ • Laid-back beach community • Ocean & Intracoastal access • Retiree-friendly

Featured neighborhoods include: Davis Shores, Vilano Beach, St. Augustine Beach, Downtown St. Augustine, Stonehurst Plantation, Southlake, Hamptons Golf & CC, and St. Johns Golf & CC.

Location & Commuting

St. Augustine occupies the southern portion of St. Johns County along Florida's Atlantic coast. Despite its small-city charm, it has strong highway connectivity:

The A1A Scenic and Historic Coastal Byway connects Vilano Beach through downtown to Anastasia Island and south to Crescent Beach. US-1 and I-95 provide north-south highway access. The compact city size means most local destinations are 5–15 minutes from each other, and the downtown historic district is highly walkable and bikeable.

Schools & Education

St. Augustine benefits from the St. Johns County School District — ranked #1 in Florida for seven consecutive years. Local schools include R.B. Hunt Elementary (highly rated, serving Anastasia Island families), Sebastian Middle School, and St. Augustine High School. For higher education, Flagler College occupies Henry Flagler's former Ponce de Leon Hotel — a Spanish Renaissance masterpiece that doubles as a working liberal arts campus recognized as a "Best Value College" by U.S. News. The University of St. Augustine for Health Sciences offers graduate programs in physical therapy, occupational therapy, and other health fields. The Florida School for the Deaf and Blind, a state-supported residential school, is also located in St. Augustine.

Buying a Home in St. Augustine

St. Augustine's real estate market rewards buyers who understand its distinct micro-markets. The historic downtown neighborhoods command premiums for walkability and architectural character — renovated Victorians in Lincolnville or Fullerwood start around $350,000 and can exceed $2 million for bayfront estates on Water Street. Across the Bridge of Lions, Davis Shores on Anastasia Island features mid-1920s development with Matanzas Bay views at a median around $665,000. Further south on Anastasia Island, St. Augustine Beach delivers oceanfront and near-ocean living from $600,000 to well over $3 million. Vilano Beach offers a more laid-back alternative north of downtown, with homes from $400,000 to $1.5 million+. Gated golf communities like Marsh Creek provide country club amenities from $500,000 to over $1 million. Condos throughout the area start around $225,000. The investment appeal is strong — vacation rental demand is year-round thanks to the city's status as one of Florida's top tourist destinations, and the combination of #1 schools and historic charm ensures long-term value.

When St. Augustine May Not Be the Right Fit

  • If you need a short Jacksonville commute: Downtown Jacksonville is 35–40 minutes via I-95. For commuters working in downtown Jax, San Marco, Southside, or Baymeadows in Duval County are significantly closer.
  • If you want master-planned community amenities: Historic St. Augustine is mostly traditional neighborhoods without resort pools, clubhouses, or trails. Nocatee, SilverLeaf, and Shearwater deliver that lifestyle in St. Johns County.
  • If tourist traffic bothers you: St. Augustine is a major tourist destination — downtown and the beaches see seasonal crowds, especially during festivals, Nights of Lights (Nov–Jan), and summer. Residents learn to navigate the timing, but it is a real factor.
  • If you want all-new construction at accessible prices: Most historic St. Augustine and beach homes are older construction. For new builds starting in the $300Ks, look to Nocatee, SilverLeaf, Shearwater, or Trailmark in northern St. Johns County.

Search the Newest Listings in St. Augustine, FL

Price
Beds
Baths
Postal Code: 32080
Postal Code: 32084
Postal Code: 32086
Purchase Type: For Sale

787 Properties for Sale

The average price in the selected areas has remained stable. Learn more

Compare St. Augustine to Nearby Communities

St. Augustine offers a lifestyle unlike anywhere else in Northeast Florida. Here’s how it compares to other communities in the region:

Ponte Vedra Beach

25 min north along A1A. TPC Sawgrass, THE PLAYERS Championship, oceanfront estates $500K–$10M+. Ponte Vedra delivers luxury golf and beach living with proximity to Jacksonville employers; St. Augustine delivers historic character, cultural richness, and a walkable downtown at more accessible prices.

Nocatee

20 min north via I-95. America’s top-selling master-planned community with water parks, 31+ miles of trails, and brand-new construction from the $300Ks. Nocatee delivers resort amenities and new homes; St. Augustine delivers 460 years of history, Atlantic beaches, and a one-of-a-kind walkable downtown that can’t be replicated.

St. Johns County (North)

Northern St. Johns County communities like SilverLeaf, Palencia, World Golf Village, and Shearwater offer new construction with community amenities at $300K–$800K+. Northern SJC delivers newer homes and golf communities; St. Augustine delivers historic architecture, coastal culture, and tourist-destination prestige.

Jacksonville Beach

35 min north in Duval County. 4.1 miles Atlantic shoreline, walkable dining and nightlife, surf culture. Jacksonville Beach delivers urban beach nightlife and shorter Jax commutes; St. Augustine delivers Florida’s best schools, lower taxes, historic charm, and a broader range of coastal neighborhoods.

The St. Augustine Advantage

No other city in Florida — or in America — combines what St. Augustine delivers: a 460-year-old walkable historic downtown with a 17th-century Spanish fort, Gilded Age architecture, and a pedestrian-only shopping street; Atlantic Ocean beaches minutes from your door on Anastasia Island; the #1-ranked public school district in Florida; the lowest property taxes in Northeast Florida; no state income tax; year-round vacation rental demand that supports investment returns; and a cultural calendar with over 40 annual festivals. The lifestyle is Charleston meets the beach, at Florida prices, with the best schools in the state. Get a free home evaluation or schedule a consultation with the Reel Keeper Home Team.

Frequently Asked Questions About St. Augustine

Why is St. Augustine called the Oldest City?

St. Augustine was founded on September 8, 1565, by Spanish explorer Pedro Menéndez de Avilés, making it the oldest continuously inhabited European-established settlement in the United States. It predates the English colony at Jamestown, Virginia by 42 years and the Pilgrims’ landing at Plymouth Rock by 55 years. The city has been continuously occupied under Spanish, British, and American rule for over 460 years. Today it preserves this legacy through landmarks like the Castillo de San Marcos (17th-century coquina fort), Flagler College (housed in Henry Flagler’s 1888 Hotel Ponce de León), and the cobblestone streets and colonial architecture of the historic district.

How much do homes cost in St. Augustine?

St. Augustine’s real estate varies significantly by neighborhood. The overall median home price is approximately $450,000–$560,000. In the historic downtown neighborhoods (Lincolnville, Fullerwood, Abbott Tract), renovated homes range from $350,000 to over $2 million for bayfront estates. Davis Shores on Anastasia Island has a median around $665,000. St. Augustine Beach oceanfront homes range from $600,000 to $3 million+. Vilano Beach homes range from $400,000 to $1.5 million+. Gated golf communities like Marsh Creek range from $500,000 to over $1 million. Condos and townhomes start around $225,000. Homes spend an average of 51 days on the market.

What are the best neighborhoods in St. Augustine?

The Historic Downtown neighborhoods — Lincolnville, Fullerwood, Abbott Tract, and North City — offer walkable living near Flagler College and the Castillo de San Marcos with Victorian, Colonial, and Craftsman homes. Davis Shores on Anastasia Island sits across the Bridge of Lions with Matanzas Bay views. St. Augustine Beach delivers oceanfront and near-ocean living on the southern end of Anastasia Island. Vilano Beach provides laid-back beach living north of downtown. Gated golf communities like Marsh Creek, Stonehurst Plantation, and St. Johns Golf & CC offer country club amenities. St. Augustine Shores provides affordable established neighborhoods in the 32086 zip code.

What is Anastasia Island?

Anastasia Island is a barrier island located directly across the Bridge of Lions from downtown St. Augustine, bounded by the Matanzas River/Intracoastal Waterway to the west and the Atlantic Ocean to the east. The island extends from the St. Augustine Inlet south to Matanzas Inlet at Crescent Beach. It includes the neighborhoods of Davis Shores, St. Augustine Beach, Lighthouse Park, and numerous gated communities including Marsh Creek, Anastasia Dunes, Sea Colony, and Ocean Palms. Anastasia State Park occupies 1,600 acres on the island with beaches, trails, and camping. The St. Augustine Lighthouse (1871) and the Alligator Farm are located here. Housing styles range from mid-1920s bungalows to new oceanfront construction, with a median around $594,000–$645,000.

What is Davis Shores?

Davis Shores is a residential neighborhood on the northern tip of Anastasia Island, developed in the mid-1920s by D.P. Davis on reclaimed marshland. The neighborhood sits directly across the Bridge of Lions from downtown St. Augustine, offering picturesque views of Matanzas Bay, the Bridge of Lions, and the downtown skyline. With a median home price around $665,000, Davis Shores features a mix of older character homes and newer construction. Its prime location provides the closest Anastasia Island living to downtown’s restaurants, galleries, and historic sites — many residents walk or bike across the bridge. The neighborhood includes waterfront properties along the bay and Intracoastal Waterway.

What is Vilano Beach?

Vilano Beach is a laid-back coastal community located just north of downtown St. Augustine, approximately 5 minutes from the historic district via A1A. Known as one of Florida’s top retiree destinations, Vilano Beach offers a quieter alternative to the more developed St. Augustine Beach. The community features both ocean and Intracoastal Waterway access, with homes ranging from $400,000 to $1.5 million+. The Villages of Vilano is a popular neighborhood within the area. Vilano Beach connects to downtown via the Vilano Bridge and provides access to the Guana Tolomato Matanzas National Estuarine Research Reserve, one of the largest protected estuarine systems on the Atlantic coast.

What schools serve St. Augustine?

St. Augustine is served by the St. Johns County School District, ranked #1 in Florida for seven consecutive years. Local schools include R.B. Hunt Elementary (highly rated, serving Anastasia Island), Sebastian Middle School, and St. Augustine High School. The district consistently produces the highest test scores and graduation rates in the state. For higher education, Flagler College is a respected private liberal arts institution recognized as a “Best Value College” by U.S. News, and the University of St. Augustine for Health Sciences offers graduate programs in health fields. The Florida School for the Deaf and Blind, a state-supported residential school, is also located in the city.

Is St. Augustine a good investment?

St. Augustine offers strong investment fundamentals. As one of Florida’s most-visited tourist destinations with over 40 annual festivals and year-round appeal, vacation rental demand is consistent and growing. The combination of the #1-ranked school district, lowest property taxes in Northeast Florida, and irreplaceable historic character creates long-term value protection. Homes in the historic district and on Anastasia Island have shown steady appreciation. The city’s small geographic footprint (roughly 13 square miles) limits supply while tourism, school quality, and lifestyle appeal drive perpetual demand. For buyers considering rental income, proximity to downtown attractions and the beaches makes many St. Augustine properties attractive for short-term rental platforms.

What is the Nights of Lights celebration?

The Nights of Lights is St. Augustine’s signature annual event, running from mid-November through late January. The entire historic district is illuminated with millions of white lights draped across buildings, trees, and landmarks, creating one of the most spectacular holiday light displays in the world. National Geographic has recognized it as one of the top 10 holiday light displays globally. The event draws visitors from across the country and makes the holiday season in St. Augustine truly magical. During Nights of Lights, residents enjoy the beauty nightly while the celebration brings economic activity to local businesses. Trolley and boat tours offer different perspectives on the display.

How does St. Augustine compare to Ponte Vedra Beach?

Both communities are in St. Johns County with access to #1-ranked schools and low property taxes. Ponte Vedra Beach (25 min north) focuses on luxury golf and oceanfront living centered around TPC Sawgrass and THE PLAYERS Championship, with homes ranging from $500,000 to $10 million+. St. Augustine offers more diverse housing stock — from $225,000 condos to $3 million+ estates — with the added dimension of 460 years of history, a walkable downtown district, cultural attractions, and a vibrant restaurant and gallery scene that Ponte Vedra lacks. Ponte Vedra delivers exclusive golf-club prestige and closer Jacksonville commutes; St. Augustine delivers historic character, cultural depth, and broader lifestyle options at generally more accessible prices.

Ready to Find Your Home in Atlantic Beach?

From oceanfront estates to walkable beach bungalows and new-construction golf course homes, the Reel Keeper Home Team know every block of Atlantic Beach. Let us help you find the right home in one of Jacksonville's most desirable coastal communities.

Schedule a Consultation

Reel Keeper Home Team

Your Jacksonville & Northeast Florida Real Estate Experts • eXp Realty

(904) 414-4000 team@viewjaxhomes.com Contact the Team
Jacksonville & Northeast Florida Community Guides
More